|
?:reviewBody
|
-
On April 8, at least 59 people, including seven children, were killed after a missile strike hit a railway station in the eastern Ukrainian city of Kramatorsk. The attack came as thousands were attempting to flee heavy Russian shelling across the region. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy initially said at least 300 people were wounded in the strike. People (were) crowded, waiting for the trains to be evacuated to the safe territory at the station, Zelenskyy said in an address to Finland's parliament . They hit these people. There are witnesses, there are videos, there are remnants of the missiles and dead people ... Why do they need to hit civilians with missiles? Why this cruelty that the world has witnessed in Bucha and other cities liberated by the Ukrainian army? As Zelenskyy condemned the attack, some started to spread rumors that it was Ukraine, not Russia, that carried it out. This unsubstantiated rumor has been pushed by Russian state media and Kremlin-linked social media accounts, and was bolstered by a supposed BBC News story that placed the blame on Ukraine. Very interesting how the train station was a war crime until we realized Ukraine did it, reads a screenshot of a tweet that was shared on Facebook on April 13. These false claims are amplified by a conspiratorial video that appears to show the BBC’s logo and watermark. But the video isn't legitimate. It doesn’t appear on the BBC’s official social media accounts , website or YouTube channel . The news organization confirmed it’s fake and said it was working to have it removed. Claims blaming Ukraine by Russian-state accounts fall short on evidence and contradict earlier posts taking credit for the strike. There is evidence of Russian military forces using the same kind of missile that hit the train station. Posts promoting this rumor were flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook .) The fake video claiming to be from the BBC The one-minute-27-second clip shows several graphic scenes, including the site of the bombing with dead people on the ground and a shot of the Tochka-U missile found nearby. The serial number of the Tochka-U missile is identical to the series of missiles from the arsenal of the 13th AFU missile brigade, text overlaid on the video says. The same type of missiles and the same serial number were previously fired by the Ukrainian army at the cities of Khartsyzsk, Logvinovo, Berdyansk, and Melitopol. The video also claims that Ukrainian media stopped reporting on the bombing after the missile factory numbers were revealed. The video was circulated by pro-Kremlin accounts on Telegram and appeared in multiple Twitter posts before most were taken down by the platform. The BBC did not report that Ukraine was behind the Kramatorsk attack. Inconsistencies with the placement of logos, location tags and style — like the lack of background commentary — are signs that the video wasn’t created by the news group. We are aware of a fake video with BBC News branding suggesting Ukraine was responsible for last week’s missile attack on Kramatorsk train station, the news organization said in an April 13 statement on its Twitter account. The BBC is taking action to have the video removed. We urge people not to share it and to check stories on the BBC News website. How claims of Ukrainian involvement fall short At a background briefing on April 8, the U.S. Defense Department said that the Kramatorsk bombing was carried out by Russian troops likely using a short-range ballistic missile known as an SS-21. Obviously, we are not buying the denial by the Russians that they weren't responsible, said someone only identified by the Defense Department as a senior defense official. I would note that they originally claimed a successful strike, and then only retracted it when there were reports of civilian casualties. So it's our full expectation that this was a Russian strike. German journalist Julian Röpcke tweeted that Kremlin-affiliated media initially reported that Russia attacked the train station, but then blamed Ukraine after learning of the casualties. His tweet included screenshots of what he said were Telegram posts boasting about the attack. Kremlin affiliated media first proudly reported the #Kramatorsk massacre, claiming their missile hit an ammunition train that arrived yesterday evening. After the appearance of civilian casualties, they started blaming Ukraine. Same story as with #MH17 in 2014. #PutinAtWar pic.twitter.com/D3yMZSshbJ — Julian Röpcke🇺🇦 (@JulianRoepcke) April 8, 2022 The Russian Defence Ministry has since denied using the Tochka-U missile, yet military analysts say that images and videos on social media refute those claims. News reports and an Amnesty International report have also pointed out recent instances of Russia using the missile system. Russian media also claimed that the serial number on the missile proves it came from the Armed Forces of Ukraine. The markings on the rocket discovered at the scene of the bombing indicate it was a Soviet-era OTR-21 Tochka missile , and the serial number, the same that appears in the fake BBC video — Ш91579 — shows it was produced in the Votkinsk Machine Building Plant, a machine and ballistic missile factory in Russia’s Udmurtia region. The plant mass-produced missiles in the Soviet era, which were then transported at different times to different countries including Kazakhstan, Russia, Belarus and Ukraine, according to reporting by Ukrainian fact-checkers at StopFake.com. The missile’s serial numbers are unrelated to the country they were shipped to, so Russia’s logic that the number indicates that the missile could only come from Ukraine is flawed. Our ruling Facebook posts claim that Ukraine was responsible for the Kramatorsk train station bombing. A video used to bolster this rumor is fake. Although the video has a BBC logo, it was not produced by the news organization. There’s no credible evidence that Ukraine was behind the attack. The Tochka missile used in the attack, and the serial number on it, isn’t proof that it came from the Ukrainian army. Several news reports, legitimate photos and videos show that Russia has used these missile systems recently. The rumors that Ukraine attacked the train station have largely been spread by pro-Kremlin social media accounts. We rate this claim False.
(en)
|
![[This page as RDF]](http://data.gesis.org/claimskg/static/rdf-icon.gif){kind=icon}