|
?:reviewBody
|
-
In September 2020, several readers asked Snopes to look into the facts surrounding high-profile news reports that claimed U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi had visited a hair salon in San Francisco, California, despite a city ordinance that required non-essential businesses to remain closed as part of broader efforts to contain the spread of the ongoing COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic. On Sept. 1, 2020, Fox News published an article with the headline Pelosi Used Shuttered San Francisco Hair Salon for Blow-Out, Owner Calls it 'Slap in the Face.' The network reported that: Other major news outlets, including CNN and USA Today, followed up on Fox News' reporting. Pelosi has claimed that she was the victim of a politically motivated setup, and the man who styled her hair has lashed out at the salon owner, claiming the latter authorized the appointment in advance, contrary to her assertion that she was outraged to hear about the visit. However, it is nonetheless true that Pelosi did visit the salon in San Francisco on Aug. 31, 2020, at a time when the city required non-essential businesses, including hair salons, to remain closed. On Sept. 1, 2020, the San Francisco Department of Public Health introduced a new set of orders (Order of the health officer No. C19-07h). Among many other provisions, the new rules relaxed existing restrictions on what the document categorized as personal service providers — hair salons, nail salons, barber shops, skin care, and so on (page 24). Beginning at 9 a.m. on that date, those businesses could operate outdoors, under certain conditions, and with certain exceptions. Until then, an earlier set of orders (issued on Aug. 14, 2020) meant that businesses like hair salons could not operate at all. Since Pelosi's visit to eSalon took place on Aug. 31, the earlier, stricter orders were still in place at that time. A spokesperson for Pelosi confirmed for Snopes that the visit had taken place, writing in an emailed statement that the business (that is, eSalon) had told her local rules allowed it: The Speaker always wears a mask and complies with local COVID requirements. This business offered for the Speaker to come in on Monday and told her they were allowed by the city to have one customer at a time in the business. The Speaker complied with the rules as presented to her by this establishment. As we have shown, any understanding that local rules allowed a hair salon at that time to operate with even one customer in the building was mistaken. The spokesperson later clarified for Snopes that Pelosi's staff had not had any contact with Kious herself and confirmed CNN's earlier reporting that the Aug. 31 salon visit came about because another stylist, who usually goes to Pelosi's home, was not available on that date but recommended a colleague from eSalon. Therefore, the appointment was arranged with that substitute stylist, and not Kious, but Kious did know about it in advance. Although Pelosi's spokesperson asserted that the Speaker always wears a mask, the security footage from the salon, provided to Fox News, clearly shows her walking between two rooms without a mask over her mouth or nose for at least a few seconds. Pelosi addressed that discrepancy in a combative exchange with reporters at an event in San Francisco on Sept. 2, 2020, which can be viewed in full here. She explained: Pelosi was asked if she thought she should apologize to service industry workers for her actions. She replied: Well I don't. I think that this salon owes me an apology for setting [me] up. She added: I take responsibility for trusting the word of a neighborhood salon that I've been to, over the years, many times, and that when they said 'We're able to accommodate people one person at a time' and that 'We can set up that time,' I trusted that. As it turns out, it was a setup. So I take responsibility for falling for a setup. And that's all I'm going to say on that. Kious appeared as a guest on Tucker Carlson's Fox News show later that evening and denied having set up Pelosi. However, around the same time, an attorney representing the stylist in question, Jonathan DeNardo, provided an explosive statement to several news outlets, including Snopes. In it, attorney Matthew Soleimanpour claimed that Kious had in fact authorized the appointment with Pelosi in advance, contrary to her assertions, and had made vitriolic and incendiary comments about the lawmaker in a phone call with DeNardo: Snopes invited Kious to respond to the allegations made in DeNardo's statement, but we did not receive a response in time for publication. Even though the restrictions on hair salons were relaxed on Sep. 1, 2020, one day after Pelosi's appointment at eSalon, it is not the case that the visit would have been allowed if she had simply waited 24 hours. The new orders, implemented on Sep. 1, 2020, allow hair salons to operate only on the condition that they provide services outdoors, and the document (page 24) emphasizes the requirement for both service provider and customer to wear a face covering at all times, including during the entire service — something Pelosi failed to do because she removed her mask for a brief period. Furthermore, Pelosi had her hair washed during the visit. If that involved the use of shampoo, it would also have contravened the new rules that stipulate shampooing, chemical hair services, and services that require the customers to remove their face coverings are not permitted at this time. Her spokesperson's explanation that Pelosi usually has her hair styled at her home also appears to go against the San Francisco orders. Both the version published on Aug. 14 (on page 18) and on Sept. 1 (on page 17) explicitly forbid hair dressers to provide in-home services. It's not clear whether, technically speaking, Pelosi herself violated the Aug. 14 orders or if only business owners or service providers can be regarded as being in breach. We asked San Francisco's COVID Command Center for clarification on that legal question, but we received a non-specific response to the effect that city officials emphasize compliance over punishment when it comes to violations of the COVID-19 orders. Pelosi claimed she was set up by Kious, the owner of eSalon, after being advised by DeNardo, the stylist, that her visit was allowed under local rules. DeNardo's attorney has claimed, on his behalf, that Kious actually authorized the appointment in advance and expressed antipathy towards the speaker of the House. Nonetheless, it remains the case that on Aug. 31, 2020, Pelosi visited the salon at a time when San Francisco barred hair salons from operating. While there, she briefly removed her face mask, something that would be prohibited even under more relaxed rules that have since been introduced. If she herself did not personally violate the rules, she undoubtedly participated in a violation of them.
(en)
|
![[This page as RDF]](http://data.gesis.org/claimskg/static/rdf-icon.gif){kind=icon}