|
?:reviewBody
|
-
In late 2019, we received multiple inquiries from readers about the veracity of a viral Facebook post that presented an account of the actor Jimmy Stewart's military service during World War II. The post claimed a profound link between the trauma Stewart suffered from flying 20 combat missions over Germany and his ability to immerse himself in the role of George Bailey, the melancholic protagonist of the classic American film (and holiday favorite) It's a Wonderful Life. On Dec. 22, 2018, Ned Forney — a writer who devotes his Facebook page to personal histories and tributes to many U.S. military service members — posted one such account of Stewart's patriotism and dedication, and the emotional scars he bore from his sacrifice: It's a stirring account, and one firmly rooted in an accurate presentation of the basic sequence of events of Stewart's involvement in World War II. However, elements of the story — the claim that Stewart was removed from flying missions over Germany because he suffered from PTSD, and descriptions of him suffering nightmares of men falling through the air screaming — appear to be rather thinly sourced and not corroborated in other accounts of the actor's military service. The version of events presented in the meme appears to have borrowed heavily from a 2016 book by the nonfiction writer Robert Matzen, called Mission: Jimmy Stewart and the Fight for Europe. The book charted Stewart's early career as an actor, his friendships and relationships, his family's history of military service, his famously close and affectionate bond with his father, and his entry into military service during World War II. However, the book attracted attention in the media for the revelatory claim that Stewart had suffered from what would now be diagnosed as PTSD, as a result of the horrors of flying 20 bombing missions over Germany, to such an extent that Stewart had to withdraw from combat missions, and that his trauma was visible to those on the set of It's a Wonderful Life. Here's what Matzen wrote in the book itself about Stewart's state of mind after returning to Hollywood from the war: On several occasions throughout the book, Matzen described Stewart as flak happy, a World War II-era phrase for symptoms of anxiety, sleeplessness, nightmares, and so on, which would now likely be diagnosed as PTSD. In one instance, he cited an interview he conducted with Lt. Barry Shillito, a fellow pilot and contemporary of Stewart's, as follows: ... Shillito was shocked at the change in his old squadron commander. Stewart was gray of face, with bags under his eyes and a furrowed brow. His full head of hair had begun to recede and was half silver. Jim had grown so thin that the skin hung from his neck. It was almost as if Jim Stewart had been imprisoned like the others. 'He went flak happy there for a while,' said Shillito. 'He wasn't flying anymore and he was quieter than I remembered.' The specific claim that Stewart had suffered nightmares about planes exploding and men falling through the air screaming appears to be of dubious origins. It comes from the prologue of Matzen's book, which is in several places written in an impressionistic style, mixing third-person narration with first-person, stream-of-consciousness prose, the latter a style that does not lend itself well to source-checking. The book reads: In every newspaper, in every magazine were stories about families who didn't recognize the boys who had come home. This isn't my son. This isn't my husband; this isn't my brother. He's so cold, so distant, and the rages, the nightmares! Oh yes, the nightmares came every night. There he was on oxygen at 20,000 feet with 190s zipping past, spraying lead and firing rockets, flak bursting about the cockpit. B-24s hit, burning, spinning out of formation. Bail out! Do you see any chutes? How many chutes? Whose ship was it? Oh no, not him! Not them! Bodies, pieces of bodies smacking off the windshield ... In the chapter notes, Matzen wrote the following about the sourcing for the prologue: The prologue was written last and drew upon all the research that came before. I interviewed dozens of Armed Services personnel about the experience of coming home from wartime and their feelings of unreality and disconnectedness from friends, family and co-workers who couldn't possibly understand what had happened overseas. It's perfectly plausible that Stewart, who led and took part in multiple bombing missions, might have experienced nightmares or had traumatic memories of those difficult experiences. However, the exploding planes claim serves as a useful warning about describing what might be a general impression of the collective experience of World War II aviators as a specific experience that Stewart himself personally had. The Facebook post's claim that Stewart was grounded for being 'flak happy' is also factually dubious. The broader assertion that Stewart had to fight to be allowed to fly combat missions, and play a more active part in the war, is fully corroborated in two other sources that we consulted: Jimmy Stewart: The Truth Behind the Legend, a book by the film historian Michael Munn; and Jimmy Stewart: Bomber Pilot, a book by Starr Smith, an author and journalist who worked alongside Stewart as an Eighth Air Force intelligence officer during World War II. According to all three sources, the higher-ups within the U.S. military preferred to deploy Stewart's fame and widespread respect among the American population by using him for propaganda purposes, morale-raising exercises, and to encourage other young men to enlist. However, Stewart was persistent in requesting combat missions, and was eventually stationed in England where he led or took part in 20 bombing missions over Germany. Neither Munn nor Smith's accounts describe Stewart as flak happy, shell-shocked, or suffering from what would now be diagnosed as PTSD. Neither account describes any nightmares or obvious trauma on Stewart's part, in detail, and neither book ascribes his supposed condition as the reason he was withdrawn from combat missions towards the end of the war. Rather, according to Smith, Stewart was promoted and moved in the spring of 1944, as part of what Smith describes in his book as a natural progression in his military career, given his frequently commended performance as a bomber pilot and squadron leader: ... Toward the end of March [1944], the news came: Major Stewart had been promoted. After flying twelve missions with the 445th Group and commanding the 703rd Squadron, he was leaving to become the operations officer of the 453rd Group, at Attleborough, or Old Buc ... When the appointment was announced, nothing was said about flying too many missions. The official word was that the 453rd needed an operations officer, and Major Stewart had been promoted to the job. I was then a combat intelligence officer with the 453rd, and met Stewart for the first time upon his arrival at Old Buc ... Since then, I have been asked many times about it. I must say that I think it highly unlikely that Stewart's mission schedule and high command's efforts to protect him had any bearing on his transfer and promotion. Smith speculates, in the book, that Col. Bob Terrill, with whom Stewart had a close affinity, might have lobbied for the transfer, but otherwise describes it as a routine air force change of assignment, adding: Stewart was a mature, knowledgeable and experienced air force officer with an operational and administrative background. And a stellar combat record. He knew the territory. In short, he was ready for promotion. And deserved it. Matzen's depiction of Stewart's state of mind as flak happy towards the end of World War II (a depiction reflected in Forney's viral Facebook post) was relatively thinly sourced, and involved only one direct quotation from a person who met the actor at that time. By contrast, two other detailed accounts of Stewart's World War II service make no mention of his having suffered symptoms equivalent to PTSD, nor claimed that such symptoms were the cause of his being gradually withdrawn from combat missions as the fighting reached its conclusion. One of those accounts was written by an Air Force intelligence officer who worked side-by-side with Stewart between the spring of 1944 and the end of the war. However, we don't have definitive evidence in either direction. Since flak happy is an inherently rather fuzzy description of symptoms, rather than a specific clinical diagnosis, it's perfectly plausible that Shillito might have seen in Stewart's demeanor clear signs of the condition (an appraisal he passed on to Matzen) whereas others who encountered him might have come to a completely different conclusion, either due to their own subjective point of view, or because Stewart acted differently around them. There's little doubt that much of the account presented in Forney's viral Facebook post was accurate. Stewart pushed back against bureaucratic delays and hesitation among military leadership and persistently requested to be allowed to play a more active role in the war effort, rather than being a mere poster boy. While stationed in England, he flew and led 20 combat missions over Germany, and received promotions and commendations, in particular for his leadership of those around him. Naturally, he keenly felt any loss of life and later described the fear he routinely felt when embarking on bombing missions. However, the available evidence is indecisive on the question of whether Stewart was so acutely affected by the horrors of World War II that he suffered nightmares, anxiety, and traumatic memories that would, today, amount to a diagnosis of PTSD. And the available evidence points against any such condition being the reason that he was gradually withdrawn from combat missions.
(en)
|
![[This page as RDF]](http://data.gesis.org/claimskg/static/rdf-icon.gif){kind=icon}