PropertyValue
?:author
?:datePublished
  • 2019-01-22 (xsd:date)
?:headline
  • Did Nancy Pelosi Say 'Just Because Someone Is Here Illegally Doesn't Mean They Broke Any of Our Laws'? (en)
?:inLanguage
?:itemReviewed
?:mentions
?:reviewBody
  • The use of the terms illegal immigrant and illegal alien to describe non-citizens who are present in the United States without documentation has become controversial in recent years, in part because of their pejorative connotations, and in part because they blur critical distinctions in immigration law. As the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has pointed out, simply being present in the U.S. in violation of federal immigration statutes is not, in and of itself, a crime: Violations of immigration law that don't involve improper entry are dealt with in civil proceedings (which can result in deportation), not criminal courts. This is the distinction most people have in mind when they say undocumented immigrants haven't necessarily broken any laws. It is also, apparently, the point argued in a statement widely attributed on social media to Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (D-California): Just because someone is here illegally doesn't mean they broke any of our laws, Pelosi supposedly said (at an unspecified time and place). Despite the implication in memes such as the one seen above that the statement is forehead-slappingly ridiculous, it is logically coherent in terms of the aforementioned legal distinction. Just because X doesn't mean Y is the same as saying Y doesn't necessarily follow from X -- i.e., someone who is here illegally hasn't necessarily broken the law. It's plausible to suppose that Pelosi holds such a view. She said in a 2006 PBS News Hour interview, for example, that not everyone who is an undocumented immigrant entered the country illegally: Judging from Pelosi's statements on her House.gov web page, we don't see that her overall stance on immigration has changed significantly in the ensuing years. While calling for strong, smart border security, she has also supported the Dream Act and the DACA program, and she has harshly condemned the Trump administration's zero tolerance immigration enforcement policy that resulted in the separation of children from their families at the U.S.-Mexico border. Even after sifting through her many pronouncements on immigration, however, we have not been able to verify that Pelosi ever said, in so many words, Just because someone is here illegally doesn't mean they broke any of our laws. We couldn't find the statement in any published sources (including books and periodicals), nor did we find sources cited in any of the social media posts attributing the quote to her. That having been said, we did run across instances of other public figures' uttering roughly the same thought. Ingrid M. Delgado, a spokesperson for the Florida Conference of Catholic Bishops, said in testimony before the Florida House Judiciary Subcommittee on Criminal Justice that Unlawful presence is not a crime. It is a civil violation. In 2016, then-California Attorney General (and now Democratic U.S. Senator) Kamala Harris tweeted that An undocumented immigrant is not a criminal. Former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, a Republican, said the following while serving as U.S. Attorney for the District of New Jersey in 2008: And in 2012, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote, in the majority opinion in the case Arizona v. United States, 567 U.S. 387, that As a general rule, it is not a crime for a removable alien to remain in the United States. We attempted to get in touch with Speaker Pelosi's office for help authenticating the quote attributed to her but did not receive a response in time for publication. (en)
?:reviewRating
rdf:type
?:url